The Herald Bulletin

Afternoon Update

Local Business

December 27, 2010

Emmett Dulaney: Contemplating E-Reader privacy

Sometimes, the most disturbing part of a discussion is that you need to have it at all. Consider the issue of e-readers, for example. For each of the past two years, the Electronic Frontier Foundation has released a guide to e-book readers and the current one, posted in December, can be found at  As the URL telegraphs, this guide isn’t your usual review of whether the Kindle has a sharper image than the Nook or why the iPad is a better bargain than the Sony Reader. Instead, this evaluation is focused solely on the privacy policies associated with each.

I’ll focus only on the Amazon Kindle since it is one I own and use. It might surprise you to know that per the policy, Amazon can log searches I do with the device – searches online for other books I might purchase, as well as for phrases within books I have purchased. Speaking of books I have purchased, they can log how many pages I read, and annotations I make.  The information they collect that specifically identifies me can be used by them, as well as law enforcement and civil litigants. The information in aggregated form (trend data versus my data) can be shared with others wanting to use it for promotional and marketing purposes.

Not surprisingly, because of these capabilities there is a push to pass legislation regulating what e-book reader companies can do.  What I find appalling is that at some point in history we reached an era when you specifically have to tell companies what they cannot do; otherwise – no matter how wrong we can all recognize it to be – it will be done.

Immanuel Kant is one of the most well-known philosophers of the past two hundred years and his Critique of Practical Reason essentially narrows the field of ethics known as Universal Rules down to this: never take any action you would not be willing to see others in the same situation take. I find it unfathomable that Amazon would think it acceptable if their undisclosed Chinese manufacturer installed similar spying technology in the Kindle. I further find it implausible that they would be willing to quietly allow the same information to be collected if it were a government (ours or another) benefitting from the data instead of them. Would they so willingly allow the collection if it were for publishing companies instead of them? It is only because the data is going to them (and covered by a user policy that so few read) that they are ok with it. They are taking actions they would not be willing to see others take.

Amazon isn’t alone in the e-reader market in collecting this data and Kant’s isn’t the only school of ethics. We can belabor the point by looking at the Golden Rule, Aristotle’s virtues and so on, but it is impossible to justify this undertaking using any of them. What is truly scary, though, is to realize that despite commonsense telling all that what they are doing is wrong, it requires legislation for them to stop.


Columns from the Falls School of Business at Anderson University  appear Tuesdays in The Herald Bulletin. This week’s columnist, Emmett Dulaney, teaches marketing and entrepreneurship.


Text Only
Local Business
  • NWS - HB0420 - Funderburk - 04 Man tries to restore father's tainted legacy When news broke earlier this month that the Anderson Dental Clinic had been shut down and several employees, including owner Sally Metzner, had been arrested, Mark Funderburk's main concern was the patients. "A lot of them kept going there because of my dad even after he passed away," he said. "And they didn't deserve this."

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • BIZ - HB0420 - Scott wise -TM Gaining an edge and spreading the word in 2014 Scott owner of Scotty’s Brewhouse with locations in Indianapolis, Muncie, Mishawaka and Bloomington, encourages business owners to interact with customers and use powerful tools such as Twitter, Facebook or even with a blog to their advantage.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • BIZ - HB0420 - Amys Attic - TM Business Profile: Hidden treasures can be found here Amy's Attic Thrift Store, which opened April 1, offers a variety of different items including clothing, accessories, furniture, yard decorations and collectibles.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Business People: April 20 A compilation of news items featuring members of the Madison County business community.

    April 19, 2014

  • NWS-HB0419-IvyTech-JC2.JPG Work begins on new Ivy Tech facility

    Motorists driving on East 60th Street near Columbus Avenue will notice heavy machinery working in preparation for a new educational facility in Anderson.

    April 18, 2014 2 Photos

  • Clark, Big Joe mug [Duplicate] 'Big Joe' Clark: Understanding the risks within fixed income investments Many retirees associate the concept of taking “risk” with the equity markets. However, as 2013 demonstrated, there is also principal risk in the fixed income arena if an untimely liquidation requires you to sell bonds and generate income.

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Heating assistance provided to 4,445 households Almost 5,000 households in Madison and Grant counties received assistance this past winter with their heating bills, members of the Central Indiana Community Action Program learned this week.

    April 18, 2014

  • Lapel obtains required number The Lapel Town Council finally has enough votes to move forward with its voluntary annexation of land south of the town.

    April 17, 2014

  • NWS - HB0418 - Susan Brooks Educators, agribusiness leaders discuss careers Citing approximately 55,000 new jobs being created annually in agribusiness, U.S. Rep. Susan Brooks brought educators and business leaders together to encourage students to consider it as a career path.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Anderson collects nearly $67,000 in bad debt

    The city of Anderson collected almost $67,000 in bad debts owed to the four utility departments in March.

    April 17, 2014

Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide