The Herald Bulletin

Evening Update

Local Business

December 27, 2010

Emmett Dulaney: Contemplating E-Reader privacy

Sometimes, the most disturbing part of a discussion is that you need to have it at all. Consider the issue of e-readers, for example. For each of the past two years, the Electronic Frontier Foundation has released a guide to e-book readers and the current one, posted in December, can be found at http://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2010/12/2010-e-book-buyers-guide-e-book-privacy.  As the URL telegraphs, this guide isn’t your usual review of whether the Kindle has a sharper image than the Nook or why the iPad is a better bargain than the Sony Reader. Instead, this evaluation is focused solely on the privacy policies associated with each.

I’ll focus only on the Amazon Kindle since it is one I own and use. It might surprise you to know that per the policy, Amazon can log searches I do with the device – searches online for other books I might purchase, as well as for phrases within books I have purchased. Speaking of books I have purchased, they can log how many pages I read, and annotations I make.  The information they collect that specifically identifies me can be used by them, as well as law enforcement and civil litigants. The information in aggregated form (trend data versus my data) can be shared with others wanting to use it for promotional and marketing purposes.

Not surprisingly, because of these capabilities there is a push to pass legislation regulating what e-book reader companies can do.  What I find appalling is that at some point in history we reached an era when you specifically have to tell companies what they cannot do; otherwise – no matter how wrong we can all recognize it to be – it will be done.

Immanuel Kant is one of the most well-known philosophers of the past two hundred years and his Critique of Practical Reason essentially narrows the field of ethics known as Universal Rules down to this: never take any action you would not be willing to see others in the same situation take. I find it unfathomable that Amazon would think it acceptable if their undisclosed Chinese manufacturer installed similar spying technology in the Kindle. I further find it implausible that they would be willing to quietly allow the same information to be collected if it were a government (ours or another) benefitting from the data instead of them. Would they so willingly allow the collection if it were for publishing companies instead of them? It is only because the data is going to them (and covered by a user policy that so few read) that they are ok with it. They are taking actions they would not be willing to see others take.

Amazon isn’t alone in the e-reader market in collecting this data and Kant’s isn’t the only school of ethics. We can belabor the point by looking at the Golden Rule, Aristotle’s virtues and so on, but it is impossible to justify this undertaking using any of them. What is truly scary, though, is to realize that despite commonsense telling all that what they are doing is wrong, it requires legislation for them to stop.

 

Columns from the Falls School of Business at Anderson University  appear Tuesdays in The Herald Bulletin. This week’s columnist, Emmett Dulaney, teaches marketing and entrepreneurship.

 

1
Text Only
Local Business
  • Charo Boyd: 'My Social Security' simplifies your life So many people buzz through extremely busy and complicated schedules these days. A smartphone in one hand, a computer in front of you, and a digital task list that never seems to end. In addition, to complicate things just a little more, there’s another event you need to add to your list — National Simplify Your Life week.

    July 28, 2014

  • nws - hb0725 - colts - jc - 4.jpg Colts camp's impact: pricey or priceless?

    Football fever is here and the city is flooded with fans eager to catch a glimpse of a favorite player. But officials say they are unclear what kind of economic impact the Indianapolis Colts training camp has on the area.

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • BIZ - HB0727 - Skill gap 2 Seeking a solution today, not tomorrow Tina Warner-Morton says she wants to open her own healthcare business because it is too difficult to work for an employer with unclear employee expectations.

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • BIZ - HB0727 - Cathy Cupboard Biz Profile Business Profile: Cathy's Cupboard focuses on customer satisfaction Cathy McPhearson opened her first storefront in June, but this is not her first venture into business. “I have always wanted to have my own business,” she said. “The problem was finding what people like, but everyone seems to like candles.”

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • IU Health Ball Memorial Hospital named Level III trauma center The Trauma Center at Indiana University Health Ball Memorial Hospital has been verified as a Level III Trauma Center by an ad hoc committee of the Committee on Trauma (COT) of the American College of Surgeons.

    July 26, 2014

  • Clark, Big Joe mug 'Big Joe' Clark: Beat the market or meet your goals? True or not, my experience tells me that goals – especially when written down – undoubtedly serve as catalysts for success. However, danger arises when a goal does not properly focus on the long term result you expect.

    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • DSC_8125.JPG Auction teaches in business, farming

    After 10 years of 4-H, saying goodbye to his animals has become a simple matter for McKennon Heald. But he said he wouldn't be surprised to see some tears from some of the younger participants. He's been there.

    July 25, 2014 2 Photos

  • Anderson, Alexandria and Elwood receive grants to tear down abandoned houses Three Madison County cities — Anderson, Alexandria and Elwood — received state grants that will be used to tear down abandoned, dilapidated houses.

    July 25, 2014

  • NWS - HB0715 - Chuck Pagano Pagano breakfast sold out A breakfast with Indianapolis Colts head coach Chuck Pagano is sold out, organizers said Wednesday.

    July 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Cellular Connection to host backpack giveaway Residents in Anderson will benefit from a national backpack giveaway campaign on Aug. 2.

    July 23, 2014

Stocks
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide