“Everywhere, the ceremony of innocence is drowned;
the best lack all conviction, while the worst
are full of passionate intensity.”
— William Butler Yeats (1919)
W.B. Yeats’ poem, “The Second Coming,” captured the global despair that followed World War I. Millions, including over 100,000 U.S. soldiers, were killed or wounded. Europe was in turmoil.
New countries were formed. New ideologies were taking root across the globe. Disease, specifically a new strain of the flu virus, eventually killed 50,000,000 people in a grim footnote to one of the bloodiest wars in human history.
Through the Great Depression and World War II, astride powerful new industrial and technological engines, a relatively young United States drove itself into the richest, most powerful nation on earth. It became the lamp-lit Promised Land for teeming masses of dispossessed people from every corner of the globe.
Although not without bumps, bruises and outright brutality, America absorbed countless millions of these immigrants into its factories, schools and neighborhoods.
They came in search of The American Dream. Many found their definition of it. Now, however, we find ourselves in a time where that Dream, even simply defined, is being called into question.
In my view, the concern is appropriate, not so much in relation to America’s military and economic might, but in terms of its position as a world leader in a time far more complex and dangerous than the period after World War I.
As simple terminology, “The American Dream”is code. It is the simplification, or oversimplification, of more complex ideas contained in the Declaration of Independence and the U.S. Constitution. As such, the phrase is limited in what it can convey.
A research center at Xavier University annually conducts a State of the American Dream survey “to gauge what [the Dream] is and to whom, to measure America’s confidence in itself and its future, and to understand the aspirations and values likely to directly impact current and future economic, political and cultural decisions.”
Here are some of the findings from the survey:
♦ The American Dream remains remarkably resilient despite a continued wave of bad news, enormous economic challenges, international uncertainty, and institutional distrust.
♦ While confidence in the economy and optimism about America’s place in the world have significantly declined, respondents are nonetheless still confident in their own personal ability to achieve their American Dream.
♦ Currently, the four most prominent definitions of The American Dream are “a good life for me and my family,” “financial security,””opportunity,” and “freedom.”
Although I do not know how many respondents participated in the Xavier University survey or anything about the social and economic status of those who did, I found the responses somewhat troublesome.
As to the first response, it does not surprise me that the American Dream remains resilient. It is, after all, an article of faith, like Scripture.
That aside, more and more, economists and researchers are finding that, as it is defined here, The American Dream may be out of reach for massive numbers of citizens, including new immigrants.
In the second point, respondents apparently make a distinction between The American Dream as a shared possibility for all, and a possibility for at least one. People play the lottery with the same idea in mind.
The last point is particularly troublesome in that it runs to the very substance of how, I suppose, most Americans define The American Dream.
To the point, its definition is interpreted in ways that are basically materialistic or self-serving: my family (my house, my car, my job), my financial security, my opportunity, and even my freedom.
These ideas, no doubt, have underpinnings in the “rugged individualis” that is so much a part of our national historical narrative, but do not reflect a vision of the future: 21st century requirements for shared learning (problem solving); shared work; personal responsibility; shared sacrifice; and shared resources.
As I suggested earlier, the term “The American Dream” is code for a larger set of ideas set down in part by the Founding Fathers. There is nothing wrong with that.
But there is something wrong if today’s adults — whether teachers, parents, or others — teach our young people an American Dream that only prepares them for obsolescence in a complex, changing world.
Have a nice day.
Primus Mootry is an Anderson resident. His
column is published each Wednesday.
“Everywhere, the ceremony of innocence is drowned;
- Ken de la Bastide: Control of GOP at stake in public primary battle Russ Willis and Mike Gaskill have been trading jabs for the past few months and recently it has escalated to the point where every incumbent officeholder in the courthouse except one is being challenged for the party’s nomination in the primary election.
- Howard Hewitt: Wine and food pairings As you really get into wine and start referring to yourself as a "foodie," simplistic advice just won't work.
- Jim Bailey: Memories from seventh grade stick in columnist’s mind Adjusting to junior high was a trying time for most of us. Maybe that’s why memories come flooding back so easily.
- Maleah Stringer: Don't ignore this face of animal abuse We are seeing more and more animal abuse in Madison County. It has always been here; perhaps people are simply stepping up and bringing us these animals. Or it could be a reflection of the heart of our community.
Ted Moss: Preparation key to good home-buying experience
Buying a home can be a time of both excitement and frustration. Planning ahead can make the process much easier. Here are a few considerations as you venture into home ownership.
Don McAllister: Adventures of a 'monuments man'
There are people in life who open doors and lift you through hard times. They disappear for years and are often never seen again, but they still summon a warm smile when they wander through your mind.
- 'Big Joe' Clark: Time to reconsider your hatred for inflation? True enough, inflation raises the price of goods and services, but that in itself does not make inflation all bad.
- Verna Davis: Be careful with the power of your words Recently, driving home from work, I was thinking about two incidents, one fiction, one real, that both bore out the same truth: Words have power.
- Susan Miller: Here's to boomer power Perhaps you’ve heard that 2014 marks the 50th anniversary of the Beatles’ arrival in America. While the Fab Four’s appearance on "The Ed Sullivan Show" was a pop culture milestone, there’s another significant half-century observance affecting millions of people this year. The “babies” of the baby boomer generation are turning 50.
- Jim Bailey: Experiencing an awesome family connection to a ragamuffin Richard Wayne Mullins was born in Richmond. To his family, he was simply Wayne. The world knew him as Rich Mullins, contemporary Christian singer and songwriter.
- More Columns Headlines