The Herald Bulletin

Morning Update

Local Education

March 27, 2013

Vouchers offer important school alternatives, supporters say

Opponents: Public money should stay with public schools

ANDERSON, Ind. — Micah Mitchell’s son, Aaron, was “getting lost in the shuffle” when he attended school in the Frankton-Lapel Community School Corp.

In classes with as many as 25 students and his attention deficit disorder, Aaron was having trouble focusing, Mitchell said.

But now that he’s in a smaller classroom setting at Anderson Christian School, he’s “doing really well.” His teacher is better able to hold Aaron’s attention and the curriculum seems to be beyond that of other elementary schools, Mitchell said.

The family isn’t paying the full price tag, over $4,000 per year, though. They’re at Anderson Christian on a 50 percent voucher. “Without the voucher (system), we wouldn’t have been able to put him in there,” Mitchell said.  

On Tuesday, the Indiana Supreme Court unanimously upheld a 2011 law providing vouchers for low- and middle-income families, clearing the way for an expansion being debated in the Indiana Statehouse. To date, over 9,000 students are on the voucher, or school choice scholarship, system statewide.

With the nation’s broadest school voucher program, Indiana’s ruling could set a precedent as other states look to build or expand programs.

While parents like Mitchell and private school officials are glad to see the program upheld, public school officials aren’t as thrilled by the news.

Anderson Community Schools Superintendent Felix Chow said there should instead be a larger focus on fixing what already exists in the public sector.

For example, if officers at a police station aren’t doing a good job or are corrupt, the local government and public don’t just go out and create another station, he said, they fix the problem.

“The question has been, fundamentally, do we use public money for private schools,” he said.

When a student leaves a public school for a private school on a voucher, the state money, or Average Daily Membership (ADM), the school district receives per student — about $6,200 in ACS’ case — goes with them.

It’s money, Frankton-Lapel Superintendent Bobby Fields said, that a struggling school district may be able to use to better assist struggling students.

“I’m not very happy about public dollars going to fund private education,” he said.

Especially since, he added, private schools don’t always have to play by the same rules.

While Frankton-Lapel is a district with high ISTEP scores and a good grade from the Indiana Department of Education, Fields said any loss of funds impacts programs schools can offer, giving them “less money to educate kids” with.

Chow also brought up the argument of the separation of church and state, since the majority of vouchers go to religion-affiliated institutions.

Tom Snell, administrator at Anderson Christian School, said it’s the families who are making the decision to switch schools, not the state.

For families who couldn’t afford a private school education before, he said, the vouchers offer just that.

“Those with the means can already make choices,” he said. “Those with a limited income, it gives them the same chance.”

Snell added that vouchers can help those not thriving in the public school system by providing quality alternatives.

Mitchell said many leave school districts because of “lackluster performances.”

He noted that a family could just as easily leave a school corporation for a charter school as it could a private one. While not a part of a school district, charter schools are still public schools that are tuition free.

“The main thing is being able to get them (the children) the best education possible,” he said.

The voucher expansion bill is awaiting action in the state Senate.

Find Dani Palmer on Facebook and @DaniPalmer_THB on Twitter, or call 640-4847.

Text Only
Local Education
  • NWS - HB0423 - Symphony for Kids - JC 31a.jpg Symphony for Kids draws Anderson-area students

    Nearly 1,000 fifth- and sixth-grade students attended the Anderson Symphony Orchestra's performance Tuesday during the annual Symphony for Kids concert at the Paramount Theatre.

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Frankton school evacuated, no bomb found

    Students were back in classes at Frankton Jr./Sr. High School after a bomb threat forced an evacuation Tuesday morning. No explosive device was found.

    April 22, 2014

  • Students to get introduction to symphony Nearly 1,000 fifth- and sixth-grade Madison County students will be going to the Paramount Theatre Tuesday for the annual Symphony for Kids concert.

    April 22, 2014

  • Ellspermann, Susan Ellspermann to deliver AU commencement address Indiana Lt. Gov. Susan Ellspermann will address the Anderson University Class of 2014 during commencement exercises on Saturday, May 10.

    April 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • FEA HB0421 Silent Movie 2 Acting without words

    Nineteen area students will take a walk down the red carpet Tuesday evening as their film projects premiere at the Paramount Theatre during the WRC Silent Film Festival.

    April 20, 2014 2 Photos

  • 2014 Debutante Cotillion participants

    The 11 participants in this year’s Debutante Cotillion Beautillion Militaire were asked a variety of questions, including their influences, words that describe themselves and favorite “words to live by.” The event begins at 4 p.m. Saturday, April 26, at Madison Park Church of God, 6607 Providence Drive. Call Antoinette Davis at 620-2229 for tickets, which are $270 per table or $30 each.

    April 19, 2014

  • NWS-HB0419-IvyTech-JC2.JPG Work begins on new Ivy Tech facility

    Motorists driving on East 60th Street near Columbus Avenue will notice heavy machinery working in preparation for a new educational facility in Anderson.

    April 18, 2014 2 Photos

  • Many schools see increases in IREAD scores More Madison County schools reported preliminary IREAD-3 test results Friday and, for the most part, officials were pleased with the results.

    April 18, 2014

  • NWS - HB0419 - Bicycle follow - JC 3 Highland staff, students donate more than $1,500 to help classmate's family

    Despite being a fresh face in the halls, students and staff honored Suncerria's memory this week raising more than $1,500 in cash donations and $300 in gift cards as well as a food basket to support her family through their grief.

    April 18, 2014 3 Photos

  • Liberty Christian makes changes to annual auction Liberty Christian School is upping the ante for its upcoming Duck-Tacular event. The school’s annual benefit auction is steering away from past forest themes to “Duck-Tacular,” a nod to the popular A&E show “Duck Dynasty.”

    April 18, 2014

Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide