The Herald Bulletin

Evening Update


August 4, 2012

Change of plans

Songers build what they want while avoiding bare minimum

ANDERSON, Ind. — As experienced real estate professionals, Floyd and Janice Songer have often given sage advice to home buyers about not over-investing in their property. They simply didn’t follow their own advice.

Experiencing the ease of getting carried away with improving their home, the Songers finally got all the features they ever wanted.

Not even intending to move into this 1962 Geeting Show Home in the first place, the couple had other plans for their retirement. Having built a new home on Lake Clearwater, they were perfectly pleased with their surroundings. Then Alzheimer’s disease affected Floyd’s mother, Billie Wisner, and suddenly their plans changed.

“She lived alone and we were taking care of her, but we couldn’t move her in with us because she couldn’t swim,” said Janice, a retired police lieutenant. “We bought this home on an estate sale because we knew we could build on here without changing the flow of the house.”

Kitchen has new cabinets

Having seen no renovations since its construction, the one-owner home was seriously dated. With an eye on changing only what was needed, they began creating a space for Billie to enjoy while remaining safely near family.

As walls were altered and moved, unseen problems reared their heads. Since the Songers felt they were in for the long haul, they built exactly what they wanted instead of sticking to the bare minimum.

“We started peeling things back to add on and one thing led to another,” said Janice, a real estate agent with Carpenter. “We had been regluing the tiles as they fell off the bathroom, but the contractor said once he jacked up the ceiling for the addition, they were all going to fall.”

That’s how Floyd, a retired SWAT team leader, ended up with the beautiful, handicap-accessible walk-in tile shower he always wanted.

Janice attempted to replace the kitchen countertops and live with the aged cabinetry. But once they learned all the cabinets were going to have to come down for other work, the couple decided not to reinsert them.

That’s how Janice ended up with her ideal kitchen. New cabinets are separated by a lovely tile backsplash and sparkling countertops.

“Once things started to snowball, we realized we would never get our money back out of the house, so we might as well plan on staying,” she said.

Counting on change

Working for an entire year before moving in, the Songers completed much of the demolition and painting themselves. Every wall and ceiling was redone — many of them moved or removed.

“The dining room had really small doorways and pocket doors and no natural light,” said Janice. “I knew that this was the time to fix anything I didn’t like.”

Unfortunately, less than a year after moving Billie into the house, she had a stroke. Her medical condition suddenly required 24-hour care and the Songers were forced to place her in a facility near her daughter.

“We always try to do the right thing,” said Janice. “We thought we were doing the right thing here. But the only thing you can count on is change. If we stay in Indiana, we want to stay in this house. We designed it the way we want it and it feels like home.”

But they aren’t sure they want to stay in Indiana. With medical concerns of their own, they are considering a move to a warmer climate. Torn between the home of their dreams and the promise of milder winters, the couple placed their home on the market to allow fate to decide.

“Everything I ever wanted is in this house,” said Janice. “That’s what makes it tough. But we don’t need this big of a house for just the two of us.”

Each week, Emma Bowen Meyer features a Madison County home. If you know of a home that should be showcased, send an e-mail to

Text Only
  • FEA - HB0413 - 0959 Starting over

    Ryan and Janae Ledbetter may not have moved far geographically, but the differences in their lifestyle and surroundings are huge. A new style of house has called for new décor and furnishings, which is suiting the family well.

    April 12, 2014 5 Photos

  • 0406 homes photo 0861 Home of a Thousand Transformations in Edgewood Kevin Miles carefully chose an Edgewood home, and then carefully chose a wife. Upon wedding Stephanie, he freely relinquished the reigns of decorating his home.

    April 5, 2014 6 Photos

  • FEA HB0330 0485 Crafting a headboard Since the headboard of a bed is often the focal point of a bedroom, crafty people are resourcefully using a number of unusual items to create an original piece with flair.

    March 29, 2014 4 Photos

  • FEA HB0323 Homes_0798 Sold at the view When Ryan and Sarah Smith moved from Little Rock, Ark., to the land of cornfields, they thought they were leaving fun-filled woods and hills behind. After touring an old home in Forest Hills, they discovered a wonderland that reminded them of home.

    March 22, 2014 6 Photos

  • FEA HB0316 Homes 0757 Topping off the kitchen Countertops can make or break a kitchen remodel. No matter how beautiful the cabinets, the eye will always be drawn to the surface area of the smooth, glossy top that will provide workspace for meal preparations.

    March 15, 2014 5 Photos

  • FEA HB0309 Homes56 Re-entering society Transitional housing for women re-entering society after incarceration has been available through the faith-based Sister 2 Sister program since December 2009, but the facility has only been able to house four women at a time. The ministry recently purchased a house that will service three times as many women.

    March 8, 2014 5 Photos

  • FEAHB03020701.JPG Oriental flair

    Trish Janutolo may have only spent 3 1/2 years in Japan, but the experience touched her life in such a way that she remains surrounded by the culture through her home accents and furnishings.

    March 1, 2014 1 Photo

  • FEA - HB0223 Homes 0662 Time for a change — again Shortly after their marriage 14 years ago, Phil and Catrina Cooper moved into a new home near Killbuck Lake. Two babies arrived and kept their itch for something new at bay for a while, but the need to shake things up resulted in a total remodel of the interior in 2011.

    February 22, 2014 6 Photos

  • FEA - HB0209 Homes 0557 Dressing the panes Many clients have been stepping into Grace Place, the new home décor shop in Anderson, and asking owners the same question: "How can I change the look of a room without a lot of expense?"

    February 8, 2014 6 Photos

  • FEA HB0202 0456 Travel treasures Sue Taylor began her life in Anderson and is enjoying her retirement years in Anderson, but traveled the world in the meantime. Remnants of her voyages fill her home, especially from her three years in Japan.

    February 1, 2014 7 Photos

Photographers’ pick
Featured Ads
More Resources from The Herald Bulletin
AP Video

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Helium debate

What do you think of Anderson's decision to have an Independence Day parade and other festivities on July 3?

That's great!
Should be OK
What a waste of money!
     View Results