Imagine this scenario:
Police show up at your door with a warrant for your arrest on suspicion of child molestation. You are completely innocent of any such accusations, but you are charged by the county prosecutor based on the testimony of a purported witness.
During the pretrial proceedings, the “witness” is discredited and the state’s case falls apart. The case never goes to trial. As you should be, you are exonerated.
This would be a harrowing experience for any citizen. The mere leveling of such accusations casts a public stigma on the accused, a stigma that doesn’t go away even after a not-guilty verdict.
Most of us would do whatever we could to clear our good names and to further distance ourselves from suspicion related to a crime we never committed. So, naturally, you might seek to have your arrest on suspicion of the charge expunged from your record. Otherwise, in this particular case, “arrested for child molestation” would follow you for the rest of your life.
Unfortunately, you would need the best attorneys and a sympathetic judge to have any chance of getting the arrest stricken from the record.
The difficulty of erasing an arrest from the record was highlighted recently by a case involving Skip Ockomon. The Anderson firefighter wants to have his arrest on suspicion of sexual misconduct expunged. Ockomon was indicted by a grand jury, but charges were eventually dropped.
From a detached, objective point of view, you can’t blame Ockomon for asking for the arrest to be expunged. He was never found guilty, so why should the arrest stick to his record?
Well, Indiana Deputy Attorney General Henry Flores Jr. argues that an arrest can be expunged only if one of the following conditions exists: no criminal charges were filed, charges were dropped because of mistaken identity, no offense was committed or there was no probable cause.
Wait a minute: Isn’t our justice system based on the tenet of “innocent until proven guilty”? One of Flores’ criteria, that no offense was committed, seems to place the onus of proving innocence on the accused party.
Whatever you think of the Skip Ockomon case, folks who are charged but never convicted should have more recourse to have the arrest stricken from their record. Not enabling them to do so ensures that the stigma of the arrest — despite the absence of an ensuing conviction — is stamped upon their past like a scarlet letter.
Imagine this scenario:
- Maureen Hayden: Prosecutors advocate was mild-mannered man of steel When Steve Johnson, longtime advocate for Indiana’s county prosecutors, died unexpectedly last week at the age of 66, I tweeted that the Statehouse had lost “a quiet voice in a place of bombast.”
- You Said It: About the failure to annex, hoodies and a GOP deal Each Monday, The Herald Bulletin publishes “You Said It,” a compilation of reader comments from www.theheraldbulletin.com coupled with responses by the newspaper’s editorial board.
- Scott Underwood: Spelling bee takes THB team effort Regardless of whether you attended The Herald Bulletin's regional spelling bee Wednesday evening in the Anderson City Building auditorium, I hope you enjoyed our coverage of it.
- Editorial: AU President Edwards cultivates common ground It would be difficult to find a person in Madison County more highly regarded than Anderson University President James Edwards, who recently announced he will step down from his post by the end of the 2014-15 academic year.
- Viewpoint: Stop the Mounds Reservoir project Shortly after moving to Muncie in 1992 my family and I visited Mounds State Park. We have since visited many times each year. We have delighted in the bountiful spring wildflowers, from the fascinating skunk cabbage found in east central Indiana's best preserved fen, to the elegant blood root and beautiful hepatica.
- Editorial: Hoodie policy reasonable but could be misconstrued Mounds Mall's "lower your hoodie" policy is an understandable safety measure, but the signs announcing it could be worded better to avoid the interpretation that a specific group is being targeted.
- Letter: New interstate project a waste of money When I first heard about it, I said, "They're gonna do what?" A lake right in the middle of Anderson. Now comes another Republican waste of money and time. A new interstate exit and entrance on Scatterfield Road.
- Letter: All humans never free of wickedness When in our history — 1610 to today — have we "turned from our wicked ways?"
- Editorial: Keep guns off school property At times, it seems like this nation has gone overboard in its gun legislation.
- Viewpoint: Residents should work together for a better Anderson Will someone please explain to me how a group of people that meet and complain, insult, and attack those attempting to do their best, and then issue threats to the same, could possibly be doing so in the name of progress or problem resolution?
- More Opinion Headlines