The Herald Bulletin

Afternoon Update

Opinion

April 30, 2013

Primus Mootry: Balancing safety, basic rights a problem in post-9/11 America

It has been nearly two years since Lauren Spierer, a 20-year-old Indiana University sophomore, disappeared without a trace. At the time, in one of these articles, I remember expressing my hopes that she would be found alive and well. As an aside, I also commented on the fact that many of her movements had been captured on surveillance cameras in the early morning hours of her disappearance.

At the time, a Bloomington rabbi said, “I think it’s really sad that those cameras aren’t already here. We would have had an answer already, and we would know where Lauren is right now if we had those cameras.” The rabbi was lamenting the fact that the city of Bloomington did not, like many other American cities, have surveillance cameras everywhere. But sometimes, Rabbi, you have to be careful what you pray for.

There is a tension between the need for government-sponsored surveillance in the interest of public safety and individual, Constitutionally guaranteed, right to privacy. To the point, you may recall that, a couple of years ago, Portland, Oregon’s Water Bureau drained 8 million gallons of water from a reservoir after a surveillance camera caught a drunken man urinating in it late one night.

It cost Portland over $70,000 to drain the water, dispose of it, and clean the reservoir. The embarrassed offender pleaded guilty and offered to pay the damages, except he had no money. Water experts said the drainage was unnecessary because such a minute amount of contamination posed no public health threat. Nonetheless, city officials defended their action because, well, people just don’t like the idea of drinking — you know.

I heard of another case, in Texas I think, where a man went into an alley to relieve himself and was caught on camera. Before he could finish, several squad cars were on the scene and he was carted off to jail for such an unlawful, unpatriotic act. I can’t remember whether they let him finish. But this is serious stuff.

The latter two cases I mentioned are somewhat frivolous, even laughable. But think of the role public and private surveillance cameras played in the killing of one of the Boston Marathon bombers and the capture of the other.

A CNN report noted, “Behind the scenes, federal investigators began to sort through what has become the norm in post-9/11 society. Thousands upon thousands of surveillance photos and videos taken from cameras at traffic lights, storefronts, parking garages, and other places along the marathon route.”

Without such surveillance, it is doubtful the two brothers allegedly (a formality, I think) responsible for the bombings would have been caught before they had a chance to commit another such heinous act. In fact, it is believed that New York’s Times Square might have been their next target. If guilty, by all means, spare no cost. Catch them. In either federal or military court, try and convict them. Bring them to justice.

But the tension between security and liberty is still with us. It cost taxpayers over $500,000 for city and state police, FBI, ATF, and other forces to capture the two terrorist suspects in Boston. Nationally, since 9/11, we have spent trillions on “homeland security.” Still, I suspect most Americans feel no safer today than they did on Sept. 11, 2001.

In the meantime, the U.S. Congress and both presidents Bush and Obama have kept in place the USA PATRIOT Act. The letters stand for Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism.

The Act was signed into law less than a month after 9/11 and, guess what, few (if any) legislators even read it.

The short of it is this. Under certain very fuzzy conditions, The PATRIOT Act allows the U.S. government to, among other things, subpoena the Internet or other businesses for your name, address, phone call records, library book checkouts, your telephone number, bank accounts, and other information. And that’s just a tiny piece of it. Many civil liberties groups have called it flat out unconstitutional.

Bottomline, are we, for the sake of security, sacrificing freedom of speech, the right to privacy, protection from illegal search and seizure, and the right to due process (including habeas corpus)? Is this the new normal for “the land of the free, and the home of the brave?” Will we ever feel safe again?

Have a nice day.

Anderson resident Primus Mootry is a retired school teacher. His column appears Wednesdays in The Herald Bulletin.

1
Text Only
Opinion
  • Editorial: Health center problem could have been avoided The lives and reputations of three healthcare professionals have been ruined by mismanagement at the Madison County Community Health Center. It could have been avoided.

    July 22, 2014

  • Bannon, Tom Viewpoint: Paramount is an investment that is paying dividends About 25 years ago the citizens of Anderson made a decision that would have a long lasting impact on the community. Instead of saving the old Paramount Theatre, which had fallen into serious disrepair, it was decided that the easy and prudent decision was to get rid of the building to create additional downtown parking. Shortly after the Paramount came down, the community got rid of another abandoned structure when the old Carnegie Building, which was the former home of the Anderson Public Library, was torn down.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • You Said It: About the reservoir, immigration and more on the Wigwam Each Monday, The Herald Bulletin publishes “You Said It,” a compilation of readers’ comments from www.theheraldbulletin.com coupled with responses by the newspaper’s editorial board.

    July 21, 2014

  • underwood mug [Duplicate] [Duplicate] Scott Underwood: Colts camp, 4-H fair demand our attention Late July is a busy, exciting time in Madison County. With the school year approaching fast, folks want to savor the long, hot (well, not so hot lately) days of July.

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Maureen Hayden: Expiring term heightens the urgency of one lawmaker’s mission State Rep. Rebecca Kubacki may have lost the Republican primary to a Tea Party challenger, but the two-term Republican from Kosciusko County is not going away quietly.

    July 20, 2014

  • Indiana State of State-12 [Duplicate] Editorial: State surplus comes at expense of Hoosiers' well-being If Indiana is taking in $59.8 million less – blamed on declines in revenues from the riverboat gambling tax, inheritance tax and individual income tax – and still is able to save $106.8 million, that extra cash isn’t being plucked from a secret forest of money trees.

    July 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • NWS - HB0727 - horse and pony - DK - 266 Editorial: 4-H members have goals, dreams

    This week's Madison County 4-H Fair is an opportunity to showcase area youth. They're proud of their work. Their hopeful of their futures. And they're willing to put their goals and dreams in the public eye.

    July 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • NWS - HB0626 - Shoot - 03 Editorial: License suspension makes sense in Roger Shoot case Some will object when a person accused of a crime is punished by a professional organization before conviction.

    July 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Letter: Wall Street should not be in politics Talk about corruption, ponzi schemes, we're looking at you, Wall Street, controlling the prices of our food, gasoline and clothing we must buy and about every company in America — while trashing President Obama, the Affordable Health Care Plan, along with every Democrat, to influence our elections, at the same time.

    July 17, 2014

  • Letter: 23 Relay for Life teams raised $40,000 As chairs of this year's American Cancer Society Relay For Life of Madison County, we would like to thank everyone for their generosity and support.

    July 17, 2014

Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Poll

Will you be attending Colts camp?

Yes, at least once
Yes, I plan multiple visits
No
     View Results