By Scott L. Miley
The Herald Bulletin
---- — INDIANAPOLIS — The warped lifestyle of the comically dark Gomez and Morticia Addams clan is summed up in one line in the musical about the family now playing in Indianapolis.
Morticia, dressed in a slinky black Goth dress, talks to her daughter who has just announced she is dating a boy from a traditional American family. Morticia responds, "Normal is an illusion."
The quote, a creation of Charles Addams, the cartoonist creator of the Addams Family saga, continues, "What is normal for a spider is chaos for the fly."
That's the deepest, and most revealing, message in "The Addams Family," a fast-paced and romantic romp playing this weekend at Clowes Memorial Hall in Indianapolis. The production, based around one night with the macabre household, gives audiences everything it expects in characters and has a few surprises up its long, black sleeve.
The ancestry of all this goes back to the 1930s when Charles Addams drew his first cartoon about a family living in a mansion with Frankenstein-ish butler Lurch, prank-filled kids Wednesday and Pugsley, and led by the eccentric married couple, Gomez and Morticia.
In 1964, the campy TV show based on the ghoulish family debuted with John Astin as Gomez and Carolyn Jones as Morticia. In 2010, an original Broadway musical opened with Nathan Lane as Gomez and Bebe Neuwirth as Morticia — stars whose fame and side glances likely carried the show across its rare dry moments.
Pacing here is quick as the plot is razor thin. Twentyish Wednesday wants to marry white-bread Lucas Beineke. The future in-laws are to meet for the first time in the Addams' house. And it works nicely, if not with some ridiculous segments, from there.
Granted, it's no humor-infused statement on racism a la "Guess Who's Coming to Dinner" or a gender-bending romp as in "La Cage aux Folles"( with which it has many similarities). But like so many boy-family-meets-girl-family tales, love and relationships win over the appearance of proper tradition. Normal is indeed an illusion.
A rich performance is turned in by the brassy Jennifer Fogarty as Wednesday; she balances a quirky romance with a deadpan Goth twist. Jesse Sharp as Gomez is a fitting find; he captures with his undying (or dying) love for Morticia.
Top scenes include a tango featuring Sharp, KeLeen Snowgren as Morticia and ghostly ancestors. The second act also includes a clever solo by Shaun Rice as Uncle Fester floating in air while singing a love song to a balloon moon.
As we remember from the TV show's theme song, this offbeat family is ooky and spooky. Likewise, "The Addams Family" musical is campy, kooky and fun.
"The Addams Family," a musical When: 7:30 p.m. today, May 15; 8 p.m. Friday, May 16; 2 and 8 p.m. Saturday, May 17; 1 and 6:30 p.m. Sunday, May 18. Where: Clowes Memorial Hall at Butler University, 46012 Sunset Avenue, Indianapolis Tickets: Through cloweshall.org or ticketmaster.com. Information at (317) 940-6444.