The Herald Bulletin

Afternoon Update


December 11, 2012

Jim Bailey: Do we add spanking to the list of possible cancer causes?

Forgive the analogy, but there has been a war on spanking going on for many years. And now it has found its way into the realm of medical research.

The latest foray is a British study of adults in Saudi Arabia (a country where corporal punishment, often severe, historically has been the norm) that strongly suggests a link between physical abuse, specifically including what we call spanking, and such maladies as cancer, heart disease and asthma. The study, published in the Journal of Behavioral Medicine, found those who had cancer were 70 percent more likely to have been beaten as a child, those with cardiac disease 30 percent more likely and those with asthma 60 percent more likely than among a similar group of healthy adults. It all supposedly has to do with stress.

It seems whatever one’s bias, a study can be cooked up to give credibility to that point of view. And it turns out there were other factors in play in the study: the healthy folks on average were younger and had more education, the latter also being true of their mothers. And the healthy group was taken from nurses and administrators, while we aren’t certain about the sick people’s backgrounds.

My, my. It makes the plethora of us who were spanked during our childhood wonder how we avoided debilitating illness. At age 73 I have yet to be diagnosed with any kind of malignancy, and my heart is in pretty good shape for a septuagenarian; I have had only a suggestion of any respiratory condition, probably owing more to my weight than to the amount of stress inflicted during my childhood by the board of education. Same for my wife and her siblings, whose discipline occasionally included something more than the palm of the hand (ever have to pick your own switch?).

And our kids? When we needed to get their attention, we occasionally resorted to a degree of physical contact. I confess mine was more threatening than real, with the result that the kids sometimes stifled laughter among their crying. Usually the threat was more than enough, though. Bonnie kept a paddle hanging in the kitchen, and when she grabbed it the kids immediately toed the line; I don’t think she ever actually used it.

Funny how something like corporal punishment that used to be considered the norm has found its way into the agenda of those fighting child abuse. Delaware, for instance, this year became the first state to pass a law effectively outlawing corporal discipline. It purports to be addressing child abuse, but it specifically redefines laws to include any act that causes “pain.” Seems to me that temporary pain is the object of spanking.

But the battle goes on. Recently when complaints were lodged about paddling at a Texas school, the school board actually expanded the school’s authority to use corporal punishment.

What next?

Jim Bailey’s column appears on Wednesday. He can be reached by email at

Text Only
  • FEA - HB0725 - 13 The Musical - JC - 1.JPG Review: Musical takes you back to being '13'

    Wanting to kill your mom and pining for a Wonderbra are typical desires young teenage girls have, but that just scratches the surface of the relatable themes in Mainstage Theatre’s production of “13: The Musical.”

    July 24, 2014 3 Photos

  • Community Briefs: July 25 A compilation of community news as published in the Friday edition of The Herald Bulletin.

    July 25, 2014

  • Live music: July 25

    Live entertainment at local venues as published in the Friday edition of The Herald Bulletin.

    July 24, 2014

  • FEA - HB0724 - Amputee Support - JC 3 Supporting limb loss awareness

    A small group of amputees gathered for the Second Annual Show Your Mettle Day at Frazier’s Dairy Maid on Friday. The event, which offered free ice cream to amputees thanks to Prevail Prosthetics and Orthotics, served as a meet and greet to help support limb loss awareness in the community.

    July 24, 2014 3 Photos

  • Jim Bailey: Now if Grace beats Bethel... Fans in the United States are just now waking up to the complexities of World Cup soccer, which is a lot more popular around the world than it is here.

    July 24, 2014

  • Community Briefs: July 24 A compilation of community news items as published in the Thursday edition of The Herald Bulletin.

    July 24, 2014

  • NWS - HB0723 - Fair Food - JC 3 The 'fairest food of all' Rides along the midway and 4-H animals may be a big draw for the county fair, but there's plenty of food people look forward to and indulge in during the Madison County 4-H Fair.

    July 23, 2014 3 Photos

  • Community Briefs: July 23 A compilation of community news items as published in the Wednesday edition of The Herald Bulletin.

    July 23, 2014

  • FEA - HB0722 - SAVI - 1 Staying strong during adversity

    When doctors told Judy Best she had cancer she was shocked, but she never lost hope.

    July 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • Community Briefs: July 22 A compilation of community news as published in the Tuesday edition of The Herald Bulletin.

    July 22, 2014

Reader Pet Photos

We're looking for your best pet photos! Share your photos of your favorite non-human companions in our new photo gallery. Click here to upload your photos

Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
More Resources from The Herald Bulletin