The Herald Bulletin

Morning Update

Sports

April 5, 2014

Rick Teverbaugh: Already time to scrap baseball replay

The new replay system being used by Major League Baseball is an abject failure and should be scrapped immediately.

Is that too quick and too harsh an assessment of this high-tech boondoggle that has been in place for only a week? No and no.

Some claim that baseball's pace is already so pedestrian that adding a few minutes per replay is hardly going to hurt. But that comment really is reflecting on the length of the game and not the pace. I will admit that the sport has its down time, but that time is neatly spaced between pitches and hitters.

Baseball has a rhythm that makes it enjoyable, and that syncopation is even more evident watching the games in person.

All of that is destroyed in the two or three minutes it takes to resolve a replay dispute.

The system itself isn't really all that bad, but it is the human element — yes that same human element they were trying to avoid — that has prevented this replay mechanism from being tolerable.

The manager comes out under the guise of having a discussion with the umpire about the call. It is a ruse. They are coming out to stall for time while someone in the dugout or clubhouse views the replay and sends him a signal on whether or not to use a challenge.

The delay is excruciating.

In the past, when the managers have come out, it was to argue the decision, mostly without any hope that it would be overturned. It was called protecting or supporting their players who were reacting to a call. Some managers made it quite entertaining — Earl Weaver and Lou Piniella come to mind.

That has been completely and unceremoniously removed from the game. It has been removed with all the care and planning of getting your tonsils removed on a street corner by a panhandler.

Text Only
Sports
  • SPT - HB0722 - Luck Dungy art George Bremer: Five favorite memories of Colts camp I thought, as a kind of primer before Wednesday's main event, I'd celebrate the fifth straight summer of the Colts at AU by sharing my five favorite memories of training camp so far.

    July 21, 2014 5 Photos

  • SPT - HB0722 - Stuckey art Pacers face uphill battle after signing Stuckey Last week, the Indiana Pacers lost Lance Stephenson. On Monday, they replaced one of the NBA's best young players with shooting guard Rodney Stuckey.

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Marcum claims Late Model win Morristown driver Jeff Marcum has watched victories in the McGunegill Engine Performance Late Models slip away this season, but that changed Saturday at Anderson Speedway.

    July 20, 2014

  • SPT-HB0720-HoosierParkart3.JPG Miller leads Champion Driver Series

    When the format was announced for Hoosier Park’s initial Champion Driver Series, it was thought that getting either the fifth or sixth pick in every race but never first or second might be a huge disadvantage. Lewayne Miller proved otherwise.

    July 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • SPT - HB0720 - Mireles art Mireles looks toward future after all-star finale Surrounded by his friends and family near midfield under the lights of Friday night, Elwood’s Sammy Mireles did something he’s never done in his career. The state’s all-time leading rusher freely absorbed a hit.

    July 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • SPT - HB0720 - Tennis Classic - JC 1 Hiatt repeats, Hammel wins first title at tennis classic There was a repeat winner and a first-time winner in the Men's A Singles and Women's A Singles championship matches on Saturday morning at the 34th annual Community Hospital Anderson Tennis Classic.

    July 19, 2014 4 Photos

  • Hucks move on in A Doubles bracket Shawn Huck doesn't have an easy decision when it comes to picking partners for the 34th Annual Community Hospital Anderson Tennis Classic.

    July 18, 2014

  • SPT - HB0718 - Tennis Classic logo Varsity mixed doubles champs crowned at Tennis Classic The scene slightly resembled a war zone and slightly a country club at Anderson University on Thursday afternoon. As Indianapolis Colts personnel started tearing down tennis court bleachers and parked what appeared to be nearly 100 golf carts in preparation for training camp starting on Thursday next week, one of the first titles was handed out in the Community Hospital Anderson Tennis Classic.

    July 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • Champion drivers ready for series opener Saturday at Hoosier Park Harness drivers were turned into handicappers on Thursday and their effectiveness in that role will be determined Saturday night.

    July 17, 2014

  • Champion Driver Series ready to roll Saturday

    Harness drivers were turned into handicappers on Thursday and their effectiveness in that role will be determined Saturday night.

    July 17, 2014

Latest Sports Photos


Click here to browse and buy photos from The Herald Bulletin

Latest Racing News