By KEN KUSMER
Associated Press Writer
INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — The U.S. Supreme Court decision to uphold Indiana’s Voter ID law marks the latest in a series of high-profile setbacks for the American Civil Liberties Union of Indiana, but observers say the trend speaks mostly to the conservative bent of the federal judiciary.
Monday’s 6-3 ruling in which the court said states can require voters to produce photo identification came on the heels of failed ACLU-Indiana challenges this month of Indiana’s “In God We Trust” license plates and of a Bureau of Motor Vehicles policy to revoke driver’s licenses if information doesn’t match Social Security records.
It also followed a 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruling last October tossing an ACLU-brought lawsuit challenging sectarian prayers in the Indiana House of Representatives because a group of taxpayers who sued over the practice did not have legal standing to do so.
Whether one supports the mission of the ACLU or opposes it, experts said, the losing streak underscores the conservative shift of the federal courts, especially since the confirmations of Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts and Associate Justice Samuel Alito more than two years ago.
“There is a losing streak of sorts in some of these high-profile cases,” said Daniel Conkle, a First Amendment and constitutional law expert at Indiana University School of Law-Bloomington. However, that doesn’t diminish the ACLU’s role, he said. “A group like the ACLU plays an important function in society in bringing cases that might be controversial.”
Ken Falk, the ACLU-Indiana’s legal director, rejected the notion that he was on a losing streak. He noted he and his two colleagues at the ACLU-Indiana win many cases that go unnoticed by the media.
By KEN KUSMER
- State News
- 3 killed in I-65 backup from chemical tanker crash A man and two of his children died after he dropped his wife off at an airport, their vehicle rear-ending a semitrailer on a backed-up Interstate 65 in rural northwest Indiana, authorities said.
Putnam County deputy charged with lying to grand jury
Federal prosecutors say a grand jury has charged a central Indiana reserve sheriff's deputy with lying to it in connection with the investigation of another deputy.
Indianapolis-San Francisco flights have good start
New nonstop flights between Indianapolis and San Francisco have been filling up with passengers during their first months in the air.
Study finds Indiana residents paying more in taxes
A national study found that Indiana residents have paid an increasing percentage of their income on state and local taxes at the same time their average income was shrinking.
Indianapolis city leaders unanimously approve deal for Pacers
The Pacers' biggest win so far this season came Monday — off the court. In exchange for providing $164 million to pay for operating costs at Bankers Life Fieldhouse over the next 10 years, the Pacers agreed to extend a lease agreement that will keep them in Indy for up to 13 more seasons.
Delaware County treasurer faces 46 felony counts
A prosecutor sought the removal of a Delaware County treasurer from office Monday after filing charges that allege theft, official misconduct and 44 counts of not depositing public funds on time.
- Study: Indiana residents paying more in taxes A national study says Indiana residents have been paying a growing percentage of their income on state and local taxes.
- Hobart mayor opposes detention center plan A northwestern Indiana mayor says he won't support the opening of a privately owned immigration detention center in his city.
Schools decline court-ordered anti-speeding talk
A western Indiana school corporation has declined a judge's order that a young woman speak to its high schools about the dangers of speeding.
Freight train kills woman in Montpelier
Authorities say a freight train has struck and killed a woman in eastern Indiana.
- More State News Headlines