10 Easy to Make Treats for Valentine's Day These recipes yield a big batch, store well and are free of common allergens - perfect for a Valentine’s Day themed party. 1. Red Velvet Cookies 2. Puppy Chow 3. Brownies 4. Chocolate Chip Cookie Bar 5. Blondies 6. Rice Krispie Treats 7. Strawberry Brownie 8. Funfetti Cookies 9. M&M Chocolate Candies Cookies 10. S’mores Pie